An In-Depth Look at Google’s Search-Generative Experience
Google changed the entire landscape of search once before, and they’re determined to do it again, this time with the help of AI. Google’s SGE, search generative experience, is a whole new ballgame for the way we search and find information online. With the goal of providing users with quick answers to complex questions, SGE uses generative AI to break down the top SERP content into a single snippet at the top of the page. The implications of SGE are huge for your site’s organic discoverability and the future of search as we know it.
We’re in the midst of a revolution in search, and it’s powered by . One of the main drivers of the changing search landscape is Google itself, which has rolled out its chatbot, , and is experimenting with AI-powered search in the form of its search generative experience. While impactful in their own right, chatbots pale in comparison to .
In no uncertain terms, SGE will fundamentally change the way that users get their questions answered and how sites are found on search engines. How will you respond to the future of search? Well, chance favors the well-prepared, so let’s dive in.
What is SGE?
- AI snapshot: The AI-generated snippet located at the top of the Google SERP that answers the users' questions. See our screenshot of the AI snapshot answering the query ‘What is the strongest bone in the human body?’ below.
- Conversational mode: Answers follow-up questions related to a topic while keeping the context of the original search.
- Vertical experiences: Provides a preferred list of features and more product details in commercial searches.
In short, Google’s AI will quickly comb the SERP, find the answer to a user’s question, and quickly create a digestible answer at the top of the SERP in a new snippet called the AI spotlight. From there, users can ask follow-up questions and interact with the AI rather than follow organic or paid links below.
Why is SGE important?
We believe that this is the single biggest change to the search landscape since Google itself. Google’s SGE will quickly provide users with the answers they need and not necessarily direct users to other sites or content. As you can see, this is going to have a huge impact on your business. Specifically, SGE will affect your site in two significant ways, from an organic discoverability perspective and a productivity perspective.
What is the impact of SGE on the SERP?
Based on the last few paragraphs, the implications here should be fairly obvious, but let’s break it down. First, consider the layout of the SERP page with the AI spotlight. The AI snippet takes up the best SERP real estate there is, pushing down the paid and organic results and even the featured snippets, and that’s before we expanded the AI-generated snippet. As you can expect, once you expand the AI spotlight section, it dominates the page, and every other result is pushed below the fold.
The impact on site traffic and the CTR of organic results will be devastating even if your rankings remain the same. And in case you thought your paid ads would be safe, we have bad news for you. The AI spotlight will take precedence over every result, whether organic, paid, or featured.
While Google’s goal remains to get its users the answers they need, SGE marks a shift in how it gets users from point A to point B. Specifically, Google used to give users answers to their questions by directing them toward helpful sites and content, ultimately taking them away from the Google SERP. With SGE, Google is encouraging users to remain on the SERP.
It’s important to remember that the AI-generated snippet is composed of information taken from high-ranking, valuable, and relevant content that appears on the SERP for a given keyword, and SGE will cite those sources in the snippet, so users can navigate to the site if they choose. However, given that users get answers to their specific questions so quickly and can use SGE to ask follow-up questions, searchers will have fewer reasons than ever to actually click on blue links on SERPs.
That said, while SGE is changing the nature of the SERP, Google does have an important reason not to completely redo it and remove links to sources, and that reason is Google Ads. through Ad revenue, so they have a vested monetary interest in serving ads that appear like organic links on the SERP. So while this is changing search, some things will still look familiar.
Another consideration is productivity. Google’s continued moves towards AI are in line with much of the search industry at the moment, and many companies are already and productivity. Those companies with experience using AI will have a head start on those that are slower to adapt.
How does SGE work?
SGE, still part of , is an early step in . But what does that mean in practice? It means that in certain instances when users have a specific question, Google’s AI will review the top-ranking SERP content on that topic and generate a specific answer to that question without the user having to click a link or visit a site.
So, if you have a specific question like: “What is the tallest tree in the world?” your Google SERP will look like this.
And that’s before you click ‘show more,’ which expands the AI snapshot even farther down the page and establishes SGE’s conversational mode, which allows users to ask follow-up questions. No matter how many follow-ups are asked, SGE will keep the context of the preceding queries.
Think about the last time you Googled something. You most likely had a specific question and didn’t want to read a full article about a blue whale to get your answer. Your users are the same way. They’re more likely to have questions like: “When is the best time of year to visit Florida?” SGE allows them to search for that specific question and get an AI-generated answer in seconds. In fact, generally, Google's AI .
Unfortunately, there’s not exactly a hard and fast rule on which queries the AI snapshot will appear for. In Google’s own words, the snapshot will appear “when appropriate… to help people quickly get an overview on a topic, with factors to consider and helpful information.”
While the “when appropriate phrasing is vague, it’s clear that Google wants to make sure its AI is passing along true and valuable information to its users. But given AI’s well-documented limitations, like providing incorrect or misleading information, providing . For example, Google may not want AI to answer if a user asks if they should see a doctor for certain health symptoms or if a financial investment is worth it. For YMYL questions, Google is still going to be cautious and steer users to correct information rather than fast information.
In short, Google is holding SGE to “an even higher standard when it comes to generating responses about certain queries where information quality is critically important.”
So we know that SGE may not appear for certain queries, but for more innocuous searches, when will Google deem it “appropriate” to provide AI-powered responses? To figure out a little about when the AI snapshot will appear based on trial and error.
For example, we’ve found that while the option to generate an AI snapshot appears on most of our searches—once SGE is activated—the snapshot tends to automatically populate when we ask a direct question to Google. For instance, we searched for “Acadia National Park,” and Google didn’t automatically populate the AI snapshot. It was unsure what we needed help with, so Google will give the option to generate an AI response, but the layout of the SERP looks much more familiar.
But when we searched a more specific question around national parks, like: what is the best national park to visit in December? That gave SGE a more specific context to work within and allowed it to quickly process an AI-generated response.
Limitations of SGE
Much like AI chatbots, generative AI output is far from perfect and requires a thorough approach to get the most out of it. Like ChatGPT and other tools, SGE will be prone to hallucinations that cause it to provide incorrect or misinterpreted information, as well as internal biases that can skew its output.
While SGE will usher in a new, more efficient way of finding answers to questions, the inclusion of AI means that it’s critical to thoroughly review each output for clarity, consistency, and accuracy.
How do I get included in the SGE answer box?
SGE will significantly harm the organic discoverability of every search result that isn’t included in the AI snapshot—and even some within the snapshot—because users will have less of a reason to follow a link to . So your best chance to keep your traffic, impressions, and CTR strong is to appear within that AI snapshot. But how do you do that?
From what we can tell, SGE will pull the most relevant and helpful snippet of the content appearing in the . So the best thing you can do is take the time before SGE is fully rolled out to prepare your site and optimize your content for an AI-powered world. Another thing to consider is schema markup, which can help set your content apart from others and help your content get pulled into SGE.
While there’s still no definitive answer to appearing in the AI snapshot, it pays to check out our in-depth SGE resources and to make sure you’re prepared for the future of search. In addition, Conductor’s comprehensive suite of content and technical SEO features help you optimize your content and properly prepare for SGE.
How does optimizing for SGE differ from traditional optimization?
One area where SGE optimizations distinguish themselves from traditional optimization efforts is in detailed schema. Schema provides context and makes it easier for search algorithms to understand your content, which should have a huge impact on SGE. The faster that an AI can break down and understand your site, the faster it can find information to provide in its AI snapshot. While schema is important for content optimizations, we expect them to only grow in importance as SGE is more widely used.
In addition to schema, SGE optimization will have many of the same considerations as content optimization, such as technical SEO and performance metrics like page speed. If your site is slow, often crashes, or is difficult to use, it makes for a poor user experience which factors into search algorithms.
How do I enable SGE?
- Open a new Google tab.
- Click the Search Labs icon.
- Find the SGE card and turn on the experiment.
- Try out an example.
SGE will not work if you’re working in an incognito tab.
Is SGE safe to use?
Yes, it’s safe. That said, like any AI, SGE has inherent flaws. For example, it can sometimes provide incorrect information, misinterpret requests, or give biased answers to questions, so you’ll need to be careful and thoroughly research a topic before taking SGE’s word.
In addition, there are privacy and security concerns with generative AI and SGE. Google already tracks your personal search data across platforms and Large Langauge Models that power generative AI tools are trained on user data. So when a user interacts with SGE, it will add that information to its knowledge base and may record the questions and prompts a user input. Plus, SGE cannot be used in incognito mode.
Overall, SGE is safe but beware of inputting any sensitive or personal information.
How is SGE different from Google Bard?
Both Google Bard and SGE are powered by generative AI, but each tool serves a different purpose. Firstly, Google Bard is not integrated into traditional Google search. It’s strictly a chatbot, like ChatGPT. However, Bard can reference the entirety of Google’s up-to-date index to create answers, whereas ChatGPT’s knowledge base has no data post-2021.
On the other hand, SGE adds AI power to a traditional Google search, incorporating AI-generated answers into the SERP to provide more efficient answers to users.
To sum everything up, Google’s search generative experience is a massive shift for search. By incorporating AI-generated responses in the SERP, Google is promoting a faster and more efficient search experience for its users. That said, it comes at the expense of sites and content that previously drove significant organic traffic at the top of SERPs. Companies are going to have to find a way to optimize their content for the AI-powered SGE or risk a devastating effect on their traffic. Welcome, everyone, to a new era of search.